Two short detective puzzles. Read the records, test the statements and decide what the evidence actually supports. Play here for free, without an account.
Training file 00 · Digital evidence
The Stationary Phone
A jewellery shop was robbed at 1:15 am. Mark Thorne says he was asleep at home. His phone did not move all night. Is that enough to support his account?
01 / STATEMENTMark Thorne
“I was home, asleep. My phone was charging beside the bed. Check the phone data.”
02 / PHONE RECORDNo recorded movement
- From
- 11:00 pm
- Until
- 7:00 am
- Movement recorded
- None
03 / HOME WI-FI LOGA different device
- 12:45 am
- Mark’s smart watch disconnected
- 2:10 am
- Mark’s smart watch reconnected
The log records the connection status. It does not record the reason for the disconnection or who was wearing the watch.
Which conclusion is supported by these records?
Reveal the Case 00 explanation
The phone’s location is not automatically its owner’s location. A person can leave a phone behind. The watch connection changes give an investigator a lead, but a disconnection can have other causes and does not tell us who was wearing it. These records weaken the proposed phone-based alibi; they do not prove that Mark left home or committed the robbery.
Detective habit: Separate what a record measures from the story someone tells about it.
The records describe two devices. Do either of them establish where Mark himself was, or why the watch disconnected?
Good reasoning. The stationary phone does not establish Mark’s location. The watch log is a lead to investigate, not proof of his guilt.
Try the second detective puzzle →
Training file 01 · Timelines
Seven Minutes Late
An envelope was reported missing from an archive at 8:20 pm. Three staff members have given statements. One account clashes with a timestamp—but only after you read the technician’s note.
01 / TECHNICIAN’S NOTECheck the camera clock
The archive camera’s displayed time was exactly seven minutes slow throughout the evening. The reception clock was correct. All three staff members refer to reception-clock time in their statements.
02 / ARCHIVE CAMERATwo recorded entries
- 8:07 pm displayed
- Mara enters the archive
- 8:10 pm displayed
- Mara leaves the archive
- 8:11 pm displayed
- Ellis enters the archive
- 8:12 pm displayed
- Ellis leaves the archive
The footage clearly identifies both people. These are the original displayed timestamps, before any correction.
03 / STAFF ACCOUNTSCompare the statements
Mara: “The last time I entered the archive was before 8:10 pm.”
Ellis: “I went into the archive at 8:18 pm and left about a minute later.”
Noor: “I printed a report at reception at 8:12 pm. I did not see who went into the archive.”
Whose statement directly conflicts with the corrected camera times?
Reveal the Case 01 explanation
Mara’s timing conflicts with the footage. A clock that is seven minutes slow shows 8:07 pm when the correct time is 8:14 pm. Mara therefore entered at 8:14 pm and left at 8:17 pm, after the time she gave. Ellis’s corrected times are 8:18–8:19 pm, matching the statement. Noor’s reception account is not contradicted by this archive footage.
That inconsistency needs explaining. It does not, by itself, establish who took the envelope.
Detective habit: Put records onto the same clock before building a timeline.
The camera clock is slow, so add seven minutes to each displayed time. Compare those corrected times with the statements.
Correct. Mara entered at 8:14 pm in reception-clock time, which conflicts with “before 8:10 pm”. A contradiction is a lead, not a verdict.